Author ORCID Identifier
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8830-0811 : Minghui Xiong
Location
Room 2
Document Type
Paper
Keywords
Legal evidence, Argumentation-based litigation game, judicial fairness and justice
Start Date
6-6-2020 10:00 AM
End Date
6-6-2020 11:00 AM
Abstract
In this paper, we will present an argumentative view of legal evidence. In an argumentation-based litigation game, the only purpose of the suitor (S) or the respondent (R) is to maximize their own legal rights while the purpose of the trier (T) is to maintain judicial fairness and justice. Different selections of evidence and different orders of presenting evidence will lead to different case-facts and even adjudicative results, the purpose of litigation is to reconcile a balance among the three parties - S, R, and T.
Reader's Reactions
Marko Novak, Evidence in Argumentation-Based Litigation (ALG): Comments on Xiong's and Du's Paper (June 2020)
Between Evidence and Facts: An Argumentative Perspective of Legal Evidence
Room 2
In this paper, we will present an argumentative view of legal evidence. In an argumentation-based litigation game, the only purpose of the suitor (S) or the respondent (R) is to maximize their own legal rights while the purpose of the trier (T) is to maintain judicial fairness and justice. Different selections of evidence and different orders of presenting evidence will lead to different case-facts and even adjudicative results, the purpose of litigation is to reconcile a balance among the three parties - S, R, and T.
