Location
Room 3
Document Type
Paper
Keywords
conceptual framework, deep disagreement, Fogelin, framework principles, rational resolution, resolution strategies, underlying principles
Start Date
4-6-2020 2:00 PM
End Date
4-6-2020 3:00 PM
Abstract
A deep disagreement is the result of clashing systems of underlying principles. Debate surrounding the possibility of the resolution of deep disagreements is ongoing. I elucidate the notion of deep disagreements by assuming their resolution is not precluded. I consider five disagreement resolution strategies offered by Steven Hales. Though I conclude that these strategies are not viable for resolving a deep disagreement, my examination allows me to identify certain key marks of an adequate solution.
Reader's Reactions
David Hitchcock, Commentary on Jason Schultchen’s “Deep disagreements and some resolution strategies that simply won’t do” (June 2020)
Included in
Deep Disagreements and Some Resolution Strategies that Simply Won't Do
Room 3
A deep disagreement is the result of clashing systems of underlying principles. Debate surrounding the possibility of the resolution of deep disagreements is ongoing. I elucidate the notion of deep disagreements by assuming their resolution is not precluded. I consider five disagreement resolution strategies offered by Steven Hales. Though I conclude that these strategies are not viable for resolving a deep disagreement, my examination allows me to identify certain key marks of an adequate solution.
